The 6 Safest Online Payment Methods for 2025

Online payments are more secure than ever, but they’re not without risks. Attackers are constantly finding new ways to steal financial data, from phishing scams to malware and data breaches. In the first three quarters of 2024 alone, over 842,000 cases of identity theft were reported in the US, with many involving compromised payment details.

No payment method is entirely immune, but some offer better protections against fraud or misuse than others. For example, credit cards provide legal safeguards and fraud detection systems, while digital wallets limit how much sensitive data you share with merchants. Understanding the pros and cons of each method can help you choose the safest way to pay online based on your needs.

In this guide, we’ll break down the five safest online payment methods, explain how attackers steal financial information, and share actionable tips to secure your transactions with tools like a VPN.

The 6 Most Secure Online Payment Methods

1. Credit Cards

The sheer amount of security features and legal protection a credit card offers makes it the most secure payment method for online shopping. 

Since the card issuers provide the payment, they must recover funds if you cancel a purchase. This also makes it very easy to reverse transactions if you make a mistake or realize someone is scamming you. 

Other protections and security features include:

• • Card Verification Value (CVV) – A 3-4 digit code on the back of your credit card used to verify purchases.
  • Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) – Optional feature that texts or emails a one-time code to use in addition to your payment information to confirm your identity.
  • Encryption – Scrambles your payment information to make it unreadable.
  • Zero fraud liability – You aren’t responsible for repaying fraudulent charges.
  • Fraud detection – Identifies and helps prevent fraudulent activity on your account and monitors for suspicious activity.

Some credit card issuers started using artificial intelligence (AI) to detect fraud. A 2024 study by Deloitte found that AI detected merchants who were compromised or at risk of being compromised by fraud 300 percent faster than non-AI methods.

Zero fraud liability is also a major bonus, but even without it, you won’t take a huge financial hit if your credit card is compromised. The Fair Credit Billing Act (FCBA) has ensured that credit card holders are only legally liable for up to $50 — regardless of how much scammers charge to your account.

Bottom Line:

Credit cards are both safe and secure, offering the best protections for fraud and the ability to reverse unauthorized transactions. They are the most reliable option for most online shoppers.

2. Digital Wallets

Digital wallets like PayPal, Google Wallet, and Apple Pay are convenient and secure, making them an ideal solution. When you make a purchase or send money to someone with PayPal, for example, you only share your payment information with PayPal and not the recipient. 

This means even if you shop on several websites, you only have to share your credit card or bank account details once — with your digital wallet of choice. This makes online payments much safer because the less you share this sensitive information, the lower the risk of identity theft. In addition to encryption, 2FA, and fraud monitoring, digital wallet services may offer the following:

• • Biometric verification: The ability to use your fingerprint or face to verify your identity for purchases or account access.
  • Data protection: These services won’t share sensitive data with merchants only what’s needed to complete the transaction.
  • App isolation: Malware risks are minimized because digital wallets only interact with certain apps on your phone.

You can use a digital wallet to make payments online and in person from your mobile phone by scanning a QR code or entering a PIN. PayPal is a widely accepted payment method, but that’s not true of all digital wallet services.

Bottom Line:

Digital wallets are secure and relatively safe, as they limit the exposure of your payment information. They’re an excellent choice for tech-savvy shoppers, especially for frequent online purchases.

3. Mobile Payment Apps

Mobile payment apps like Venmo, Cash App, and Zelle are designed for peer-to-peer transactions but are also accepted by some merchants. These apps allow you to link a bank account or debit card for quick and easy transfers. Many also use encryption and fraud detection to keep your payments secure.

Apps like Venmo and Cash App go beyond peer-to-peer payments by offering optional debit cards, which you can use for in-store purchases or ATM withdrawals. Real-time notifications can alert you to suspicious activity, adding an extra layer of security. However, some apps charge fees for certain features, and privacy concerns arise if transaction details are shared publicly by default.

Bottom Line:

Mobile payment apps are secure for personal payments and offer convenience for splitting bills or paying friends. They’re less practical for broader online shopping due to limited acceptance and potential fees.

4. Prepaid Cards

There’s no way to overspend with a prepaid card and most require very little information (if any) to activate. Prepaid cards, also known as gift cards, allow you to control your spending. They aren’t linked to your bank account, so you don’t need to worry that your banking data will be exposed – which means you get a more anonymous online shopping experience.

Features like 2FA, CVC, PINs, and random card number generation also make compromising a gift card more difficult. You can also buy them at major retailers without sharing your personal information. Just determine the amount you want to preload, grab the card, and pay the cashier. It’s that easy to get one.

Bottom Line:

Prepaid cards are secure for minimizing exposure of personal information but not as safe due to the lack of fraud protections. They work well for budgeting and anonymous transactions but not for high-value purchases.

5. Debit Card 

Debit cards make online payments cheap and convenient. They’re accepted everywhere credit cards are, and work the same way. The only major difference is that when you make a purchase, the money is immediately deducted from your bank account. As a result, you’re limited to the funds you have in your account (unless you have an agreed overdraft).

Most debit cards offer many of the same features as credit cards like fraud monitoring, encrypted transactions, and 2FA. Some also include One-Time Password (OTP) verification. An OTP token is a secure temporarily valid PIN sent via text or email. Once you enter the pin your identity and purchase are authenticated, if you don’t enter the OTP in time, you need to request a new one. Much like 2FA, OTP helps prevent identity theft by adding an extra layer of security.

Bottom Line:

Debit cards are moderately safe and secure for small transactions but don’t provide the same fraud protection or dispute resolution as credit cards. They’re a better option for controlled spending rather than large or high-risk purchases.

6. Crypto Wallets

Cryptocurrency uses blockchain technology to secure transactions and protect user anonymity. Each transaction is recorded in a decentralized ledger, making it difficult for cybercriminals to tamper with payment data. Features like two-factor authentication (2FA), encryption, and biometrics add an extra layer of security to crypto wallets.

For users who prioritize privacy, cryptocurrency is one of the most secure payment methods. It doesn’t require sharing sensitive details like credit card numbers or bank account information with merchants. Many online stores now accept major cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum.

However, cryptocurrencies have significant drawbacks. Their value is highly volatile, meaning the amount in your wallet could drop before you complete a transaction. Crypto payments are also irreversible. If you make a mistake or fall victim to a scam, there’s no way to recover your money. Additionally, not all merchants accept cryptocurrencies, making them less versatile than other payment options.

Bottom Line:

Cryptocurrencies are secure from a technological perspective but aren’t as safe for the average user due to volatility and lack of consumer protections. They’re best suited for experienced users who prioritize privacy and understand the risks.

Comparing Online Payment Methods: Pros and Cons

To help you decide which payment method suits your needs, here’s a quick comparison of the pros and cons for each option. This table breaks down the key features of credit cards, digital wallets, prepaid cards, debit cards, and cryptocurrencies, making it easier to choose based on what matters most to you—whether that’s security, safety, convenience, or anonymity.

Payment method	Pros	Cons
Credit Cards	Strong fraud protection, zero liability for unauthorized charges, widely accepted, easy to reverse transactions	Interest and fees, risk of overspending, data breaches still possible
Digital Wallets	Limits sharing of sensitive info, encryption and 2FA, convenient for online and in-person payments	Not universally accepted, account lockout risks in disputes
Mobile Payment Apps	Fast and easy for peer-to-peer transfers, optional debit cards, encrypted transactions, real-time notifications	Limited merchant acceptance, fees for instant transfers, potential privacy concerns
Prepaid Cards	Anonymous, no link to bank account, controls spending, easy to obtain	No fraud protection, limited acceptance, loss of funds if card is lost or stolen
Debit Cards	Widely accepted, direct access to funds, features like OTP and 2FA	Limited fraud protection, immediate withdrawal of funds, overdraft fees
Cryptocurrencies	High security and anonymity, decentralized ledger, no need to share sensitive info	Highly volatile, irreversible transactions, limited acceptance, requires technical knowledge

Ways Attackers Steal Payment Data & How to Stop Them

Phishing Emails

You likely receive legitimate emails from e-commerce sites you follow with links to special offers. Unfortunately, attackers have found ways to make phishing emails look almost identical to the ones you receive from the real store or service, by using authentic logos and product information. Many fraudsters don’t even attempt to hide their use of an Outlook or Gmail address. 

Most legitimate promotional emails are ‘do not reply.’ If you find someone is using an email address for spamming, mark the email as Spam to help save the next person and alert the mail platform of the user’s activity. Mainstream email services like Microsoft Outlook, Gmail, and Yahoo Mail provide spam filters. While they don’t catch every spam email, using the filter may keep you from falling victim to a phishing attempt.

Social Media Platforms

Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, and other social media platforms are full of ads and reels offering special discounts on products and services, but not all are legitimate. Sometimes when you click the link and enter your payment information, they take your money and never send you the product. You’re lucky if they only charge that one transaction to your payment method. 

Many scammers use your financial information to continue to make charges. When you see an ad for a can’t-miss deal on your favorite social media site, go directly to the supposed source. You can usually find the deal on their official app or website if it’s authentic. You should also take steps to increase your social media privacy, including using security and privacy tools provided by the platform.

Texting & Messaging Apps

We’ve all received a random message via text or a messaging platform (e.g. WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Google Chat) with a link to a ‘special offer.’ Sometimes from a site you’ve never heard of. If you click on the link or download the app, instead of a deal your device ends up riddled with malware.

You can minimize this cyber threat by activating security features for text and messaging platforms and practicing good judgment. Only allow people you know to contact you via FB messenger and similar tools, block unknown or unverified numbers, and never click on a link you’re unsure of. Using security and privacy tools that block malicious domains, can help you identify untrustworthy links.

Rerouting Your Web Traffic

A cybercriminal can intercept your traffic en route and redirect you to a fraudulent site if they get the right information. Even if you don’t purchase anything from the fraudulent site, being sent to the page could trigger malware downloads. 

Cybersecurity tools like VPNs hide your IP address and encrypt your traffic, so you don’t have to worry about someone redirecting your traffic to scammy websites. A VPN reroutes your data through one of its secure servers, changing your IP address and making it practically impossible to track your activity and interrupt your connection.

Cracking E-commerce Sites Security Measures

Flaws in website security can make it easier for attackers to crack anti-theft measures an e-commerce site has in place. That means any financial information you saved to your account could end up in the hands of a cybercriminal. One of the best ways to combat this attack is to use secure payment methods like PayPal or cryptocurrency.

Always practice good cyber hygiene. If you use credit or debit cards try to use HTTPS versions or websites and look for those that provide encryption for transactions. You can also secure your internet connection with a high-quality VPN like CyberGhost. We scramble your online traffic with military-grade encryption, making it useless to anyone who intercepts it. 

Keep Your Financial Information Safe

No online payment method is 100% safe unless you practice proper cyber hygiene and watch for fraudulent websites and scams. Ensure links and communications are authentic, use built-in privacy measures, monitor your account for unauthorized activity, and use strong passwords and pins. 

Get CyberGhost VPN and make all your online transactions safer – regardless of your payment method. We use military-grade VPN encryption to protect your private data and our user-friendly apps are available for all major operating systems, including macOS, Windows, Linux, Android, and iOS. That way, you can shop or pay bills from any device with more privacy and security.

Get CyberGhost VPN

FAQ